Skip to main content

Full text of "Less access to less information by and about the U.S. Government xxxi: a 1998 chronology: June – December"

See other formats


ALA  Washington  Office  Chronology 
INFORMATION  ACCESS 

American  Library  Association,  Washington  Office 

1301  Pennsylvania  Avenue,  NW,  Suite  403 

Washington,  D.C.  20004  -1701 

Tel:  202-628-8410    Fax:  202-628-8419    E-mail:  alawash@alawash.org 

http://www.ala.org/washoff 

December  1998 


Less  Access  to  Less 

Information  By  and  About 

THE  U.S.  Government:  XXXI 

A  1998  Chronology:  June  -  December 


Digitized  by  tlie  Internet  Arcliive 

in  2010 


http://www.archive.org/cletails/lessaccesstoless31amer 


Less  Access  to  Less  Information  By  and  About 

THE  U.S.  Government:  XXXI 

A  1998  Chronology:  June  -  December 


CONTENTS 


Introduction 4 

June 

Agencies  Find  It  Difficult  to  Comply  with  Electronic 

Freedom  of  Information  Law 5 

July 

Thousands  of  Nixon  Records  Destroyed 5 

CIA  Breaks  Promises  to  Release  Cold  War  Files 5 

FBI  Exemption  to  Declassification  Order  Revealed 6 

September 

Sen.  Moynihan  Thinks  Secrecy  Is  for  Losers 6 

October 

Military  Required  to  Remove  Information  from  Public 

Websites 7 

House  Members  Angry  at  Secrecy  Surrounding  Huge 

Omnibus  Appropriations  Bill 7 

Automatic  Declassification  of  Government 

Documents  Halted 8 

Defense  Department  Blacks  Out  General  Pinochet 

Biographic  Sketch 8 

November 

CIA  Refuses  to  Reveal  Names  of  Human  Rights  Violators  ....  8 
Switch  from  Paper  to  Electronic  Distribution  of  2000 

Census  Data  Raises  Information  Issues 8 

EPA  Decides  to  Withhold  Disaster  Information  from  the 

Internet 9 

Supreme  Court  Stops  Case  Because  of  Secrecy 9 

Controversy  Could  Lead  to  Less  Accurate  Census 10 

December 

Annual  Report  on  Declassification  Identifies  Lingering 

Problems 10 

Nixon  Papers  Controversy  Continues  in  New  Trail 10 

Federal  Agency  Holds  Secret  Information  about  Princess 

Diana 1 1 

Democrats  and  Republicans  Clash  over  FBI  Documents II 

CIA  Fights  Release  of  Budget  Information 1 1 


OPENNESS — Some  examples  are  also 

AVAILABLE  ABOUT  "MORE  AcCESS"  DURING  THIS 

SAME  period: 

June 

Secret  Navy  Data  Declassified   12 

The  FBI  Makes  Secrets  Available  on  the  Internet 12 

Patent  Database  to  Be  Freely  Available  on  the  Internet 12 

July 

Tobacco  Documents  Made  More  Accessible  to  the  Public 12 

Judge  Tells  FDA  Not  to  Block  Drug  Data 13 

August 

Bill  Would  Open  Nazi  Records 13 

Declassification  Ordered  of  Selected  Cold  War  Documents....  13 

September 

JFK  Assassination  Records  Released 13 

October 

Head  of  CIA  Publications  Review  Board  Takes  Pride  In 

What  He  Has  "Left  In" 14 

National  Security  Archive  Mounts  Collection  of 

Declassified  Documents 14 

November 

National  Archives  Becomes  Trove  of  Declassified  World 

War  II  Documents 14 

The  COGI  James  Madison  Awards  honor 

champions  of  the  public's  right  to  know 15 


Less  Access  •  June  -  December  1998  •  3 


Less  Access  to  Less  Information  By  and  About 

THE  U.S.  Government:  XXXI 

A  1998  Chronology:  June  -  December 

Introduction 


For  the  past  17  years,  this  ongoing  selective 
chronology  has  documented  efforts  to 
restrict  and  privatize  government  information. 
It  is  distributed  at  ALA's  Midwinter  and 
Annual  Conferences  and  as  an  electronic 
publication  at  http://www.ala.org/washoff/ 
lessaccess.html.  While  government 
information  is  more  accessible  through 
computer  networks  and  the  Freedom  of 
Information  Act,  there  are  still  barriers  to 
public  access.    Disclosure  that  federal 
agencies  are  failing  to  make  public 
information  available  on  their  World  Wide 
Web  sites  or  withdrawing  it  for  security 
reasons  raises  concerns  about  public  access  to 
government  information  in  the  present  and 
future. 

Another  development,  with  major 
implications  for  public  access,  is  the  growing 
tendency  of  federal  agencies  to  use  computer 
and  telecommunication  technologies  for  data 
collection,  storage,  retrieval,  and 
dissemination.    This  trend  has  resulted  in  the 
increased  emergence  of  contractual 
arrangements  with  commercial  firms  to 
disseminate  information  collected  at  taxpayer 
expense,  higher  user  charges  for  government 
information,  and  the  proliferation  of 
government  information  available  in 
electronic  format  only.  This  trend  toward 
electronic  dissemination  is  occurring  in  all 
three  branches  of  government.    While 
automation  clearly  offers  promises  of  savings, 
will  public  access  to  government  information 
be  further  restricted  for  people  who  cannot 
afford  computers  or  pay  for  computer  time? 

On  the  other  hand,  the  Government  Printing 
Office  GPO  Access  system  and  the  Library  of 


Congress  THOMAS  system  have  enhanced 
public  access  by  providing  free  online  access 
to  government  databases. 

Recognizing  that  some  federal  agencies  are 
succeeding  in  increasing  public  access  to 
government  information,  this  update  also 
includes  selected  examples  of  such  successes. 

ALA  continues  to  reaffirm  its  long-standing 
conviction  that  open  government  is  vital  to  a 
democracy.    A  January  1984  resolution  passed 
by  ALA's  Council  stated  that  "there  should  be 
equal  and  ready  access  to  data  collected, 
compiled,  produced,  and  published  in  any 
format  by  the  government  of  the  United 
States." 

In  1986,  ALA  initiated  a  Coalition  on 
Government  Information.    The  Coalition's 
objectives  are  to  focus  national  attention  on 
all  efforts  that  limit  access  to  government 
information,  and  to  develop  support  for 
improvements  in  access  to  government 
information.  Since  1989,  the  Coalition  has 
presented  the  James  Madison  Award  to 
champions  of  the  public's  right  to  know.   The 
awardees  are  listed  in  this  update. 

With  access  to  information  a  major  ALA 
priority,  library  advocates  should  be 
concerned  about  barriers  to  public  access  to 
government  information.    Previous 
chronologies  were  compiled  in  two  ALA 
Washington  Office  indexed  publications,  Less 
Access  to  Less  Information  By  and  About  the 
U.S.  Government:  A  1981-1987  Chronology, 
and  Less  Access    to  Less  Information  By  and 
About  the  U.S.  Government:  A  1988-1991 
Chronology.    The  following  selected 
chronology  continues  the  tradition  of  a  semi- 
annual update.  ♦ 


4  •  ALA  Washington  Office 


Chronology 


June 

Agencies  Find  It  Difficult  to  Comply  with 
Electronic  Freedom  of  Information  Law 

Backlogs  in  processing  traditional  paper-based 
requests  under  the  Freedom  of  Information  Act  are 
hindering  some  federal  agencies  from  complying 
with  the  requirements  of  the  1996  Electronic 
Freedom  of  Information  Act.   At  a  hearing  of  the 
House  Subcommittee  on  Government 
Management,  Information  and  Technology,  chaired 
by  Rep.  Steve  Horn  (R-CA),  a  FBI  spokesman  said 
the  agency  has  a  backlog  of  nearly  1 1,900  requests 
for  information.  Technical  difficulties  in  Web  site 
development  have  also  stymied  agencies  from 
EFOIA  compliance,  said  Richard  Huff,  co-director 
of  the  Justice  Department's  Office  of  Information 
and  Privacy. 

Patrice  McDermott  of  OMB  Watch,  an 
organization  that  monitors  public  access  to 
government  records,  said  that  of  the  57  federal 
agencies  her  organization  had  surveyed  recently, 
none  had  complied  fully  with  EFOIA.   She  cited 
three  reasons  for  the  lack  of  compliance:   lack  of 
Congressional  funding,  lack  of  guidance  to 
agencies  from  the  Office  of  Management  and 
Budget,  and  the  failure  of  agencies  to  make  access 
to  federal  information  a  priority.   "The  goal  of 
EFOIA  should  be  to  make  so  much  information 
publicly  available  online  that  Freedom  of 
Information  Act  requests  become  an  avenue  of  last 
resort,"  McDermott  said.  (Tillett,  L.  Scott.  "Feds 
find  EFOIA  a  tough  act  to  follow,"  Federal 
Computer  Week,  June  15,  1998,  18.) 

July 

Thousands  of  Nixon  Records  Destroyed 

In  early  June  the  National  Archives  and  Records 
Administration  shredded  more  than  70,000  pages 
of  documents  about  former  President  Richard  M. 
Nixon.  Then  the  shreds  were  stuffed  into  126  burn 


bags  and  incinerated  at  the  Pentagon.    The 
records,  not  classified  or  related  to  national 
security,  were  logs  summing  up  what  have  been 
deemed  to  be  "private/personal"  or 
"private/political"  conversations  on  the  former 
president's  White  House  tapes.    The  documents 
were  covered  by  a  federal  court  order  that  requires 
the  Archives  to  return  to  the  Nixon  estate  all  the 
"personal  and  private"  conversations  scattered 
throughout  his  original  White  House  tapes. 

Archivist  John  Carlin  is  trying  to  decide  what  to 
do  with  the  fragile,  original  tapes.  It  is  estimated 
that  it  would  take  five  years  to  edit  the  3,700  hours 
of  tape.  Additionally  trying  to  edit  out  the  819 
hours  of  "personal"  discussions  would  probably 
destroy  most  of  the  original  tapes  including 
segments  concerning  the  Watergate  scandal. 
Some  archival  specialists  suggest  a  bonfire  for  the 
original  tapes,  too.   "Cutting  and  splicing  them  is 
going  to  be  a  monumental  waste  of  time,"  one  said. 
"Once  you  start  cutting,  you've  destroyed  the 
tapes."   (Lardner,  George.   "Nixon  Logs  Burn  to 
Ashes,"  The  Washington  Post,  July  1,  1998,  A21.) 

[Ed.  Note:  Previous  chronologies  reported  on 
earlier  developments  about  the  Nixon  tapes.] 

CIA  Breaks  Promises  to  Release  Cold  War  Files 

Citing  lack  of  funds  and  personnel,  George  Tenet, 
director  of  the  Central  Intelligence  Agency, 
announced  that  the  agency  will  not  release  secret 
records  about  most  of  its  major  cold  war  covert 
operations  in  the  foreseeable  future.  The  CIA 
promised  five  years  ago  to  declassify  thousands  of 
files  on  1 1  major  paramilitary  and  political 
operations  carried  out  under  Presidents  Truman, 
Eisenhower  and  Kennedy.  Some  documents  from 
two  of  the  operations  have  been  published:  the 
1961  Bay  of  Pigs  invasion  of  Cuba  and  the  1954 
coup  against  the  Guatemalan  government.   But 
Tenet's  statement  made  it  clear  that  the  agency 
never  undertook  a  serious  effort  to  declassify  the 
remaining  nine  operations. 
Information  about  the  nine  operations  make  up  a 


Less  Access  •  June  -  December  1998  •  5 


secret  history  of  American  power  used  against 
foreign  government.  The  CIA  also  promised  six 
years  ago  to  release  records  of  its  coup  in  Iran  in 
1954.  It  belatedly  acknowledged  last  year  that 
most  of  those  files  had  been  destroyed  in  the 
1960s.  Tenet  said  the  CIA  had  released  227,000 
pages  to  a  government  panel  on  the  assassination 
of  President  Kennedy  and  reams  of  information  for 
the  official  histories  of  the  State  Department  of  the 
1950s  and  1960s.  These  releases  took  precedence 
over  the  voluntary  effort  to  declassify  covert 
actions. 

Page  Putnam  Miller,  director  of  the  National 
Coordinating  Committee  for  the  Promotion  of 
History,  said,  "There  are  no  resources  now  for  this 
project."  A  CIA  spokeswoman  said  about  150 
people  work  on  declassification,  handling  requests 
from  the  White  House,  Congress,  State 
Department,  and  requests  under  the  Freedom  of 
Information  Act.   She  said  the  amount  of  money 
spent  on  the  effort  could  not  be  revealed  because  it 
was  secret.  ("Weiner,  Tim.   "CIA,  Breaking 
Promises,  Put  Off  Release  of  Cold  War  Files,"  The 
New  York  Times,  July  15,  1998,  A13.) 

FBI  Exemption  to  Declassification  Order 
Revealed 

In  1995  when  President  Clinton  signed  an 
executive  order  directing  the  automatic 
declassification  of  millions  of  government  secrets 
more  than  25  years  old,  he  did  not  mention  that  the 
Federal  Bureau  of  Information  would  have  a 
blanket  exemption.  FBI  officials  defended  the 
previously  undisclosed  exemption,  saying  it  was 
essential  because  of  the  size  of  its  files — 6.5 
million  cubic  feet — where  classified  and 
unclassified  files  are  mingled,  often  without  labels 
that  show  those  supposed  to  concern  national 
security.   No  other  government  agency,  including 
the  CIA  and  the  super-secret  National  Security 
Agency,  won  an  exemption.   "It  sounds  like  we 
pulled  a  real  coup,"  one  FBI  agent  said. 

The  arrangement  came  to  light  in  court  papers  in 
June  and  was  laid  out  in  detail  in  a  memo  obtained 
by  The  Washington  Post  under  the  Freedom  of 
Information  Act.  Critics  of  government  secrecy 


said  that  the  exemption  was  legally  questionable 
because  it  has  no  cut-off  date  and  because  the  FBI 
used  federal  privacy  law  instead  of  any  national 
security  concerns  to  justify  it.  It  is  uncertain  how 
and  why  the  special  arrangement  for  the  FBI  came 
about.   "The  understanding  was  that  there  was  a 
distinction  between  making  something  public  and 
removing  any  classification  from  it,"  said  former 
National  Security  Council  staff  member  Morton 
Halperin.   "These  files  were  not  going  to  be 
automatically  put  in  a  public  library  after  25  years. 
They  would  still  be  subject  to  law  enforcement  and 
privacy  reviews.   So  therefore  this  [automatic 
declassification]  was  not  a  big  threat  to  them." 
(Lardner,  George.   "FBI  Won  Exception  to 
Presidential  Order  Declassifying  Secrets,"  The 
Washington  Post,  July  19,  1998,  A03.) 

September 

Sen.  Moynihan  Thinks  Secrecy  Is  for  Losers 

In  his  book.  Secrecy:  The  American  Experience, 
Sen.  Daniel  Patrick  Moynihan  (D-NY)  offered 
advice  to  public  officials  considering  whether  or 
not  to  keep  information  confidential:  When  in 
doubt,  put  it  out.  Moynihan  drew  on  the  work  of 
the  Commission  on  Protecting  and  Reducing 
Government  Secrecy  (1995-97),  which  he  chaired, 
to  write  a  history  of  official  secrecy  in  America. 

Moynihan  wrote  that  a  case  can  be  made  that 
secrecy  is  for  losers  —  both  people  and  policies. 
He  asserted  that  Richard  Nixon's  rage  at  the 
publication  of  the  top-secret  Pentagon  Papers  in 
1971  eventually  led  to  the  Watergate  break-in  and 
ultimately  his  resignation.    Additionally,  he 
believes  that  the  covert  Bay  of  Pigs  fiasco  in  1961 
"arguably  led  to  the  Cuban  missile  crisis  of  1962," 
the  most  dangerous  moment  of  the  Cold  War. 

Moynihan  argued  that  overclassification  stifles 
analysis  and  debate  (the  reason  the  CIA  did  not 
foresee  the  collapse  of  the  Soviet  Union);  it  deters 
self-criticism  that  is  fundamental  to  democracy; 
and  its  feeds  suspicions  of  conspiracy.  He  said  that 
the  benefits  of  publication  are  rarely  weighed  when 
classifiers  v/orry  about  the  harm  that  may  result 
from  disclosure  of  information.   Knowledge  is 


6  •  ALA  Washington  Office 


power,  Moynihan  concluded,  and  if  other  people 
have  less  knowledge,  the  official  has  more  power. 
(Turner,  Robert  L.  "Putting  the  Word  Out  on 
'Secrecy,'"  The  Boston  Globe,  September  29,  1998, 

C2.) 

October 

Military  Required  to  Remove  Information  from 
Public  Web  Sites 

Deputy  Secretary  of  Defense  John  Hamre  issued  a 
directive  on  September  25  requiring  all  Department 
of  Defense  organizations  to  remove  certain 
information  from  public  military  Web  sites.  Plans 
for  military  operations,  movements  of  military 
units  and  personal  data  such  as  Social  Security 
numbers,  phone  numbers  and  addresses  of  military 
personnel  family  members  were  included.  The 
threat  of  terror  attacks  against  military  people  and 
installations  was  the  justification  for  the  directive. 

The  impact  of  the  directive  was  not  immediately 
clear  since  few,  if  any,  military  Web  sites  have 
content  that  has  not  cleared  for  release.  However, 
the  new  directive  might  make  it  more  difficult  to 
decide  what  may  be  released.  Among  the  materials 
that  may  go  under  wraps  are  maps,  biographies  of 
and  speeches  by  civilian  officials.   "By  looking  at 
various  speeches,  you  might  find  that  the  person 
might  reference  his  parents  and  where  they  live,"  a 
spokesman  said.   "If  you  connect  bios  with  the 
speeches,  you  could  get  personal  information  about 
civilian  officials."    However,  removing  maps  from 
Web  sites  would  not  do  much  for  security  because 
maps  appear  in  guidebooks  that  are  available  to  the 
public.    The  Defense  Department  recognizes  that 
the  information  on  its  Web  sites  is  public 
information  and  that  the  public  could  obtain  it  by 
going  to  a  military  installation  or  filing  a  Freedom 
of  Information  Act.   But  making  information  so 
easily  accessible  on  the  Internet  concerns  Defense 
officials. 

Internet  freedom  advocates  expressed  concern 
that  officials  may  use  threats  to  personnel  as  an 
excuse  to  keep  legitimate  information  from  the 
public.  "If  this  is  taken  as  an  excuse  to  take  out 


budget  information,  information  on  weapons 
systems,  and  so  on  it  would  be  a  travesty  on  the 
American  people,"  said  William  Arkin,  an 
independent  defense  analyst.  The  Pentagon's  main 
Web  site  (at  http://www.defenselink.mil)  branches 
into  separate  Web  sites  for  each  military  branch 
and  some  individual  units  and  ships.  Some  bases 
have  independent  sites.   (Ratnam,  Gopal.   "Defense 
Reviews  Sensitivity  of  Web  Site  Data,"  Federal 
Times,  October  12,  1998,  4.) 

House  Members  Angry  at  Secrecy  Surrounding 
Huge  Omnibus  Appropriations  Bill 

Numerous  rank  and  file  Members  of  Congress 
criticized  the  House  leadership  for  secretly  stuffing 
millions  of  dollars  in  controversial  projects  into  the 
$520  billion  omnibus  appropriations  bill  that  was 
prepared  as  the  105th  Congress  moved  toward 
adjournment.   Republicans  were  angered  when 
their  leadership  blocked  them  from  examining  the 
details  of  the  pending  funding  legislation.    "We 
have  negotiated  a  bill  we  can't  read  with  people  we 
don't  trust  and  spent  money  we  don't  have  for 
things  we  don't  need,"  Rep.  Steve  Largent  (R-OK) 
said  of  the  funding  bill  that  passed  the  House  on 
October  20.  Republicans  were  particularly  angry 
with  Speaker  of  the  House  Newt  Gingrich  (R-GA) 
and  Appropriations  Chair  Robert  Livingston  (R- 
LA)  for  allegedly  "hiding"  the  details  of  the  40- 
pound,  4,000-page  bill  until  just  hours  before  the 
final  vote. 

On  the  Senate  side.  Sen.  John  McCain  (R-AZ) 
said,  "The  process  by  which  the  bill  was  created  is 
deplorable.  Negotiations  were  conducted  behind 
closed  doors,  out  of  sight  of  the  public  as  well  as 
the  vast  majority  of  Members  of  Congress. 
Decisions  were  made  and  then  reversed  without 
notice."   Sen.  Daniel  Patrick  Moynihan  (D-NY) 
criticized  Congressional  leaders  for  writing  nearly 
one-third  of  the  $1.7  trillion  budget  behind  closed 
doors.   "We  are  beginning  to  resemble  a  kind  of 
bastard  parliamentary  system  in  which  the  real 
decisions  are  made  in  a  closed  room  by  three  or 
four  people,"  he  said.  Republicans  were  equally 
infuriated  that  the  budget  plan  was  available  for 
only  a  few  to  see.  (VandeHei,  Jim  and  Ethan 


Less  Access  •  June  -  December  1998  •  7 


Wallison.   "Budget  Fight  Ends,  But  Few  Are 
Happy,"  Roll  Call,  October  22,  1998,  1.) 

Automatic  Declassification  of  Government 
Documents  Halted 

Automatic  declassification  of  classified  records 
more  than  25  years  old  was  halted  by  a  provision 
inserted  into  the  defense  authorization  bill  for 
FY1999  (P.L.  105-261).  Decried  by  critics  as  a 
major  blow  to  secrecy  reform,  the  law  directs 
government  agencies  to  revert  to  a  page-by-page 
review  of  all  classified  records  more  than  25  years 
old.    This  painstaking  and  time  consuming  review 
is  required  until  the  Department  of  Energy  and  the 
National  Archives  develop  procedures  determining 
which  of  their  documents  are  "highly  unlikely"  to 
contain  "Restricted  Data"  or  "Formerly  Restricted 
Date,"  as  nuclear  secrets  are  called. 

As  he  signed  H.R.  3616,  President  Clinton 
stated:   "I  am  disappointed  that  the  Congress,  in  a 
well-meaning  effort  to  further  protect  nuclear 
weapons  information,  has  included  an  overly  broad 
provision  that  impedes  my  Administration's  work 
to  declassify  historically  valuable  records.  I  am 
committed  to  submitting  the  plan  required  under 
this  Act  within  90  days.  In  the  meantime,  I  will 
interpret  this  provision  in  a  manner  that  will  assure 
the  maximum  continuity  of  agency  efforts,  as 
directed  by  my  Executive  Order  12958,  to 
declassify  historically  valuable  records."   (Miller, 
Page  Putnam.   "President  Critical  of  Restrictive 
Declassification  Provision  in  Defense 
Authorization  Act,"  NCC  Washington  Update,  vol. 
4,  no.  42,  October  26,  1998  [http://www.h-net.msu. 
edu/~ncc/].) 

Defense  Department  Blacks  Out  General 
Pinochet  Biographic  Sketch 

When  the  U.S.  Defense  Intelligence  Agency 
released  a  biographic  sketch  of  General  Augusto 
Pinochet,  it  blacked  out  everything  on  the  page 
other  than  the  date,  his  name,  and  his  position  as 
the  President  and  Chief  of  the  Military  Junta  in 
Chile.  The  document,  released  under  the  Freedom 
of  Information  Act,  is  one  page  of  thousands  of 


secret  documents  buried  in  Washington.    A  picture 
of  the  black  page  was  featured  in  The  New  York 
Times.  (Kornbluh,  Peter.   "Op-Art:  Defense 
Intelligence  Agency,"  The  New  York  Times, 
October  26,  1998,  A25.) 

November 

CIA  Refuses  to  Reveal  Names  of  Human  Rights 
Violators 

In  a  newly  declassified  report  written  by  its 
inspector  general,  the  Central  Intelligence  Agency 
refused  to  give  human  rights  investigators  in 
Honduras  the  names  of  Honduran  military  officers 
suspected  of  executing  a  leader  of 
counterinsurgency  operations  in  1983.  Despite 
deletions,  the  report  acknowledged  for  the  first 
time  that  the  CIA  knew  at  the  time  of  "death 
squad"  activities  linked  to  Honduran  military 
personnel  with  whom  the  U.S.  government  had 
close  ties.  The  report  also  acknowledged  that  CIA 
officials  failed  to  fully  reveal  the  extent  of  human 
rights  violations  in  Honduras  to  agency 
headquarters  or  to  Congress. 

The  agency's  deletions  of  names  again  ignited  a 
debate  over  legislation  that  would  have  required 
the  CIA  to  disclose  information  even  if  it  revealed 
the  identity  of  confidential  intelligence  sources. 
The  Senate  narrowly  defeated  legislation  that 
would  have  prohibited  the  CIA  from  withholding 
information  about  an  individual's  involvement  in 
human  rights  abuses  "solely  because  that  individual 
was  or  is  an  intelligence  source."  The  bill  also 
established  an  expedited  declassification  process 
for  documents  sought  by  human  rights 
investigators  in  Honduras  and  Guatemala  and 
created  a  panel  to  review  declassification  decisions 
made  by  the  CIA.   (Loeb,  Vernon.   "CIA  Won't 
Name  Hondurans  Suspected  of  Executing  Rebel," 
The  Washington  Post,  November  4,  1998,  A2.) 

Switch  from  Paper  to  Electronic  Distribution  of 
2000  Census  Data  Raises  Information  Issues 

The  Census  Bureau  is  planning  to  mount  most  of 
the  2000  census  data  on  the  Internet,  with  little 


8  •  ALA  Washington  Office 


being  distributed  in  paper.   Although  the  plan  is 
likely  to  result  in  a  profusion  of  private-sector 
packaging  of  government  information,  there 
appears  to  be  little  concern  about  whether  the 
quality  and  veracity  of  government  data  could  be 
compromised  by  marketers  who  may  enhance  the 
materials  in  their  zeal  to  tailor  it  for  business 
clients.  Others  express  concerns  about  the  Internet 
being  used  as  the  primary  method  for 
disseminating  federal  statistics  without  a  national 
policy  for  cyberspace  information  storage  and 
retrieval.   "What  the  Census  Bureau  is  doing  is  just 
the  tip  of  a  much  bigger  iceberg,"  said  Gary  Bass, 
executive  director  of  OMB  Watch,  an  organization 
that  monitors  public  access  to  government  records. 
"The  government  doesn't  have  a  plan  for  regulating 
its  data.   [Federal  officials]  can't,  or  shouldn't,  be 
putting  it  out  there  willy-nilly  because  what  they 
are  releasing  affects  us  all." 

Although  some  experts  worry  about  policy 
implications,  entrepreneurs  are  eager  to  download 
information  produced  by  the  Census  Bureau, 
repackage  it,  and  sell  it  at  a  profit.  Mike  Bergman, 
a  Census  Bureau  spokesman,  said,  "The  idea  is  to 
put  this  new  system  in  place  and  allow  people  to 
do  the  sophisticated  number-crunching  themselves 
online."  Bureau  officials  said  their  Web  site 
(http://www.census.gov)  is  already  among  the  most 
popular  in  the  world.   Don  Wynegar,  chief  of 
marketing  services  at  the  bureau  said,  "Once  we 
have  the  data  up  on  our  Web  site,  it  will  generate 
opportunities  for  middlemen  to  repackage  the  data 
and  sell  it.  Millions  of  people  who  have  access  to 
the  Internet  will  be  able  to  dial  us  up.  There  will 
be  numerous  vendors  looking  for  ways  to  use  the 
materials.  We're  giving  it  away."  (Fulwood,  Sam. 
"U.S.  Counting  on  Web  to  Be  Census  Source  Data: 
Bureau  Plans  to  Post  Most  of  Its  2000  Enumeration 
Data  on  the  Internet."  Los  Angeles  Times,  Home 
Edition,  November  15,  1998,  28.) 

EPA  Decides  to  Withhold  Disaster  Information 
from  the  Internet 

The  1990  Clean  Air  Act  requires  facilities  that  use 
large  amounts  of  extremely  hazardous  substances 
to  prepare  Risk  Management  Plans  (RMP), 


including  worst-case  accident  scenarios.    The 
Environmental  Protection  Agency,  which 
implements  the  law,  has  decided  not  to  proceed 
with  a  plan  to  put  the  complete  scenarios  on  the 
Internet.    Intense  pressure  from  Congress,  law- 
enforcement  agencies  and  the  chemical  industry 
apparently  caused  the  change  in  policy.  EPA  said 
that  it  had  been  eager  to  place  the  disaster 
scenarios  on  the  Internet,  but  now  it  will  post  some 
basic  information  about  chemicals  at  the  plants, 
including  which  chemicals  are  being  stored  and 
used  and  emergency-response  plans  for  those 
places.  Some  Members  of  Congress,  the  FBI,  and 
the  CIA  opposed  the  plan,  maintaining  that  broadly 
available  disaster  information  could  be  used  by 
terrorists.  Environmental  groups  said  the  publicly 
accessible  database  would  help  Americans  identify 
threats  in  their  backyards,  and  that  the  more  public 
information  that  is  available  about  chemicals  in 
neighborhoods,  the  more  pressure  there  will  be  to 
reduce  the  use  of  these  chemicals.  (Borenstein, 
Seth.   "EPA  Keeps  Data  on  Disaster  Scenarios  Off 
Internet,"  The  Philadelphia  Inquirer,  November  19, 
1998,  A13.) 

Supreme  Court  Stops  Case  Because  of  Secrecy 

On  November  2  the  Supreme  Court  declined  to 
hear  two  cases  brought  by  employees  at  a  top- 
secret  Air  Force  base  near  Groom  Lake,  NV.  The 
plaintiffs,  former  workers  and  two  widows  of  men 
who  worked  at  the  base,  claim  they  were  exposed 
to  high  levels  of  hazardous  waste.  A  district  court 
had  dismissed  the  cases,  finding  that  a  trial  would 
be  impossible  because  of  the  Air  Force's  right  to 
keep  secret  national  security  information.  Among 
the  secret  information  the  Defense  Department,  the 
co-defendant  with  the  Environmental  Protection 
Agency,  was  allowed  to  withhold  from  the 
plaintiffs  was  whether  hazardous  materials  were 
generated,  stored  or  disposed  of  at  the  base  known 
as  Area  51.  Both  widows  claimed  that  the  death  of 
their  husbands  was  job-related.  The  case  is  Stella 
Kasza  et  al.  vs.  EPA  et  ai,  98-5405,  U.S.  Supreme 
Court,  November  2,  1998.  (Harris,  Christy. 
"Secrecy  Stops  Widows'  Claims,"  Federal  Times, 
November  23,  1998,4.) 


Less  Access  •  June  -  December  1998 


Controversy  Could  Lead  to  Less  Accurate 
Census 

Controversy  continues  to  surround  the  method  of 
counting  the  population  to  be  used  in  the  2000 
census.  Trying  to  correct  an  undercount  of  about  4 
million  people  in  the  1990  census,  Census  Bureau 
officials  have  planned  to  use  statistical  sampling  to 
reduce  the  disproportionate  undercount  of  racial 
minorities  in  the  2000  census.  Some  members  of 
the  Census  Monitoring  Board,  a  congressionally- 
appointed  bipartisan  board,  have  suggested  the 
Census  Bureau  eliminate  "scientific  sampling" 
from  the  2000  census  by  using  Medicaid,  food 
stamp,  driver's  license  and  similar  files.  Resisting 
the  suggestion.  Census  Bureau  officials  said  that 
for  years  they  have  been  testing  the  feasibility  of 
gathering,  matching  and  verifying  data  from 
federal,  state  and  local  agencies.  They  have  found 
that  some  state  officials  fail  to  release  needed 
records,  and  files  they  could  use  with  special 
permission  often  were  dated,  error-riddled  and 
incomplete  for  census  use.  Officials  said  relying 
extensively  on  administrative  records  would  raise 
costs  and  take  more  time  than  the  agency  now  has. 
For  various  reasons  some  Members  of  Congress 
and  others  oppose  sampling,  which  the  Census 
Bureau  says  would  be  more  accurate  and  less 
costly  than  the  traditional  methods.  Additionally, 
sampling  twice  has  been  ruled  illegal.    These 
rulings  have  been  appealed  and  the  Supreme  Court 
heard  arguments  on  sampling's  legality  on 
November  30.  Justices  are  expected  to  rule  on  the 
issues  by  July  1999.  The  cases  are  Department  of 
Commerce  vs.  House  of  Representatives,  No.  98- 
404,  and  Clinton  vs.  Glavin,  No.  98-564.  (Gribbin, 
August.   "Census  officials  see  problems  with 
suggestion  to  use  files,"  The  Washington  Times, 
November  24,  1998,  A4.) 


December 

Annual  Report  on  Declassification  Identifies 
Lingering  Problems 

At  the  end  of  August,  the  Information  Security 
Office  released  its  annual  report  for  FY  1997 
concerning  its  implementation  of  Executive  Order 
12958  on  national  security  policy  and 
declassification  of  government  records.  Although 
positive  trends  were  highlighted,  it  also  identified 
lingering  problems. 

The  report  said  start-up  and  compliance  among 
the  major  classifying  agencies  has  been  uneven. 
Additionally,  the  rate  of  declassification  at  several 
agencies  is  lagging  because  of  an  apparent 
unwillingness  to  alter  an  extremely  cautious 
approach  to  declassification.  Several  agencies  will 
not  declassify  any  information  that  has  not 
undergone  a  line-by-line  review  by  several 
reviewers,  notwithstanding  the  age  of  the 
documents  or  their  subject  matter.   Resource 
limitations  are  having  a  clear  impact  on  agency 
compliance  and  oversight.  In  some  instances, 
declassification  activity  has  been  so  prolific  that  it 
exceeds  the  ability  of  agency  systems  and 
resources  to  process  the  records  for  public  access, 
or  even  the  ability  to  advise  other  agencies  and  the 
public  about  what  information  has  been 
declassified.  The  "Information  Security  Oversight 
Office:  1997  Report  to  the  President"  is  available 
at  the  Web  site  of  the  Federal  of  American 
Scientists  at  http://www.fas.org/sgp/isoo/ 
isoo97.html  (Miller,  Page  Putnam.  NCC 
Washington  Update,  vol.  4,  no.  46,  December  1, 
1998). 

Nixon  Papers  Controversy  Continues  in  New 
Trail 

A  long-delayed  trial  to  determine  the  "just 
compensation"  due  to  former  President  Nixon's 
estate  opened  in  a  federal  court.  The  Nixon 
lawyers  say  that  the  former  president's  White 
House  tapes  and  papers  have  a  "fair  market  value" 
of  up  to  $213  million  dollars.  Government  lawyers 
sought  to  show  that  Nixon  never  intended  to  sell 


10  •  ALA  Washington  Office 


them  and  could  not  have  done  so  without  years  of 
laborious  processing.  A  Nixon  attorney  said  that 
Congress  abrogated  an  agreement  to  donate  his 
records  to  the  National  Archives  when  Congress 
passed  a  law  in  1974  confiscating  Nixon's  records 
and  thwarting  his  hopes  of  having  them  housed  in 
a  traditional  presidential  library.  Congress  acted  to 
prevent  Nixon  from  destroying  his  tapes  and  to 
provide  the  public  "with  the  full  truth"  about  the 
abuses  of  power  that  forced  him  from  office. 
(Lardner,  George.   "Nixon  Agreement  on  Donating 
Papers  Cited,"  The  Washington  Post,  December  4, 
1998,  AlO.) 

Federal  Agency  Holds  Secret  Information  about 
Princess  Diana 

In  the  process  of  denying  a  Freedom  of 
Information  Act  request,  the  National  Security 
Agency  revealed  that  it  had  a  1,056-page  file  on 
the  late  Princess  Diana.  An  NSA  spokesperson 
said  that  the  documents  had  been  classified  top 
secret  "because  their  disclosure  could  reasonably 
be  expected  to  cause  exceptionally  grave  damage 
to  the  national  security." 

The  super-secret  spy  agency  was  involved  in  an 
additional  controversy  in  Europe.  Last  January  a 
report  released  by  the  European  Parliament 
concluded,  "within  Europe,  all  e-mail,  telephone 
and  fax  communications  are  routinely  intercepted 
by  the  United  States  National  Security  Agency." 
The  report  focused  on  a  system  called  Echelon 
through  which  NSA  and  its  spy  partners  in  Britain, 
Canada,  New  Zealand  and  Australia  share 
communications  intercepted  world-wide  and  divide 
the  huge  task  of  analyzing  the  "take."   "Each  of  the 
five  [countries]  supply  'dictionaries'  to  the  other 
four  of  keywords,  phrases,  people  and  places  to 
'tag,'  and  the  tagged  intercept  is  forwarded  straight 
to  the  requesting  country,"  according  to  the  report. 

Steven  Aftergood,  of  the  Federation  of  American 
Scientists,  said  he  could  not  understand  why  the 
Echelon  controversy  has  gone  unnoticed  in  the 
United  States.   He  acknowledged  that  the  lack  of 
interest  might  result  from  the  fact  that  law 
prohibits  NSA  from  targeting  American  citizens 
for  communications  intercepts,  here  or  abroad. 


(Loeb,  Vernon.   "NSA  Admits  to  Holding  Secret 
Information  On  Princess  Diana,"  The  Washington 
Post,  December  12,  1998,  A13.) 

Democrats  and  Republicans  Clash  over  FBI 
Documents 

Democratic  Members  of  Congress  have  accused 
Republican  Judiciary  Committee  members  of 
trying  to  increase  support  for  President  Clinton's 
impeachment  based  on  unproven  and  "misleading" 
information.  The  materials  at  issue  are  sealed  FBI 
documents  containing  unsubstantiated  allegations 
about  the  President  that  were  not  included  in  the 
public  material  accompanying  Independent 
Counsel  Kenneth  Starr's  report  to  Congress. 

Democrats  on  the  House  Judiciary  Committee 
were  furious  over  the  inspections  of  the  sealed 
documents.  They  accused  Republicans  of 
circulating  unfounded  rumors  about  the  president 
and  of  failing  to  tell  Democrats  that  the  sealed 
documents  were  available  in  an  area  for  "secured" 
information  in  the  Gerald  R.  Ford  congressional 
building.  Jim  Jordan,  spokesman  for  the 
Committee's  Democrats,  said,  "The  material  was 
withheld  of  the  committee... because  it's 
unsubstantiated,  ambiguous  and  misleading." 

Sam  Stratman,  spokesman  for  Committee  Chair 
Henry  Hyde  (R-IL),  said  the  inspections  to  the 
sealed  documents  were  proper.  He  added  that 
when  the  House  formally  created  its  impeachment 
inquiry  in  October,  it  granted  every  member  access 
to  all  the  documents  accumulated  by  Starr, 
including  those  not  made  public.   (Goldstein,  Amy 
and  Juliet  Eilperin.   "Democrats,  GOP  Clash  over 
FBI  Documents,"  The  Washington  Post,  December 
19,  1998,  A36.) 

CIA  Fights  Release  of  Budget  Information 

A  Washington  Post  editorial  criticized  the  Central 
Intelligence  Agency  for  actively  opposing  a  lawsuit 
requesting  the  CIA's  intelligence  budget  request  for 
1999.    The  editorial  encouraged  the  CIA  to 
reconsider  its  position,  arguing  that  "the 
government's  unwillingness  to  disclose  the  budget 
request  smacks  of  reflexive  government  secrecy 


Less  Access  •  June  -  December  1998  •  11 


and  of  an  unreadiness  of  the  agency  to  subject 
itself  to  the  most  rudimentary  pubHc 
accountabiUty." 

In  1997  and  1998  the  CIA  did  release  aggregated 
intelligence  budget  information  in  response  to  a 
Freedom  of  Information  Act  lawsuit  by  the 
Federation  of  American  Scientists.  In  1996  the 
bipartisan  Commission  on  the  Roles  and 
Capabilities  of  the  United  States  Intelligence 
Community  recommended  that  the  disclosure  of 
both  budget  requests  and  appropriations  every  year 
could  be  done  "in  a  manner  that  does  not  raise  a 
significant  security  concern." 

CIA  Director  George  J.  Tenet  filed  a  statement 
opposing  this  latest  lawsuit,  stating  that  disclosure 
of  the  1999  figures,  along  with  previously 
disclosed  figures  for  1997  and  1998,   "provides  a 
measure  of  the  administration's  unique  critical 
assessment  of  its  own  intelligence  programs." 
Tenet  also  argued  that  release  of  such  budget 
information  "reasonably  could  be  expected  to  cause 
damage  to  the  national  security  and  would  tend  to 
reveal  intelligence  sources  and  methods."  ("A  CIA 
Secret,"  The  Washington  Post,  December  28,  1998, 
A24.) 


OPENNESS:  Some  Examples 
are  also  available  about 
"More  Access"  during  this 


SAME  period: 


June 

Secret  Navy  Data  Declassified 

Vice  President  Gore  announced  the  declassification 
and  release  of  secret  and  restricted  Navy  data.  The 
data,  of  scientific  and  commercial  value,  will  help 
increase  public  understanding  of  marine  life, 
improve  weather  forecasting  and  climate  change 
research,  and  identify  valuable  ocean  resources. 
Additionally,  the  Department  of  Defense  will 
improve  marine  safety  by  producing  computer- 


based  nautical  charts  to  replace  the  paper  charts 
used  by  mariners  for  centuries.  (White  House  Press 
Release.  "Public  Access  to  Military  Data  and 
Technology,"  June  12,  1998.) 

The  FBI  Makes  Secrets  Available  on  the 
Internet 

The  FBI  quiedy  posted  more  than  1,600  pages 
dating  back  to  the  1940s  on  its  Web  site 
(http://www.fbi.gov/),  although  most  contain 
blacked-out  passages  and  missing  names.    The 
agency  plans  to  put  up  to  1.3  million  documents 
online,  including  some  on  famous  people, 
unidentified  flying  objects,  and  alleged  alien 
abductions.   (Macavinta,  Courtney.   "FBI  posts  the 
real  "X  files,"  CNET News.Com,  June  19,  1998, 
[http://www.news.com/News/Item/ 
0,4,233343,00.html].) 

Patent  Database  to  Be  Freely  Available  on  the 
Internet 

The  Clinton  Administration  announced  that  it 
would  make  the  full  database  of  United  States 
patents  since  1976  and  trademark  text  and  images 
starting  from  the  late  1800s  freely  available  on 
Internet  at  http://www.uspto.gov/.  The  project  will 
create  the  largest  online  government  database, 
made  up  of  more  than  21  million  documents.  This 
decision  will  fuel  the  fierce  debate  between  public 
interest  advocates  who  argue  that  government 
information  should  be  available  electronically  and 
commercial  companies  that  purchase  the  data  from 
government  agencies  to  resell  for  a  profit.  ("U.S. 
Plans  Free  Public  Access  to  Patent  Database  on  the 
Web,"  San  Jose  Mercury  News,  June  25,  1998, 
4C.) 

July 

Tobacco  Documents  Made  More  Accessible  to 
the  Public 

Important  information  about  the  health  hazards  of 
tobacco  and  the  tobacco  industry's  effort  to  induce 
children  to  smoke  were  hidden  by  the  industry  for 
decades.  President  Clinton  directed  Secretary  of 


12  •  ALA  Washington  Office 


Health  and  Human  Services  Donna  E.  Shalala  to 
coordinate  a  public  health  review  of  tobacco 
industry  documents  and  develop  a  plan  to  make  the 
documents  more  accessible  to  researchers  and  the 
public  at  large.  The  plan  would:  (1)  propose  a 
method  for  coordinating  review  of  the  documents 
and  making  available  an  easily  searchable  index 
and/or  digest  of  the  reviewed  documents;  (2) 
propose  a  plan  to  disseminate  widely  the  index 
and/or  digest  as  well  as  the  documents  themselves, 
including  expanded  use  of  the  Internet;  and  (3) 
provide  a  strategy  for  coordinating  a  broad  public 
and  private  review  and  analysis  of  the  documents 
to  gain  critical  public  health  information.  (White 
House  Press  Release.  "President  Clinton  Makes 
Tobacco  Documents  More  Accessible  to  the 
Public,"  July  17,  1998.) 

Judge  Tells  FDA  Not  to  Block  Drug  Data 

U.S.  District  Judge  Royce  Lamberth  ruled  that  the 
Food  and  Drug  Administration's  ban  on  the 
distribution  to  doctors  of  scientific  journal  articles 
and  textbooks  violates  constitutional  protections 
for  commercial  speech.  At  issue  is  medical 
information  concerning  unapproved  uses  for 
pharmaceutical  companies'  products.  FDA 
officials  argued  that  the  ban  is  necessary  to  ensure 
that  companies  do  not  promote  products  by 
providing  incomplete  or  biased  information,  or 
gain  approval  for  a  drug  for  a  narrow  use  and  then 
promote  many  other  uses  through  the  distribution 
of  favorable  scientific  information.  The  Clinton 
Administration  is  likely  to  appeal  the  ruling. 
(Schwartz,  John.   "FDA  Is  Told  Not  to  Block  Drug 
Data,"  The  Washington  Post,  July  31,  1998,  A23.) 

August 

Bill  Would  Open  Nazi  Records 

Congress  passed  S.  1379,  The  Nazi  War  Crimes 
Disclosure  Act,  establishing  the  Nazi  War  Criminal 
Interagency  Working  Group  to  locate,  identify, 
inventory,  recommend  for  declassification,  and 
make  available  to  the  public  all  classified  Nazi  war 
criminal  records  of  the  United  States.  The  Act  will 
make  it  much  easier  for  historians,  researchers  and 


the  public  to  view  the  documents  dating  to  the 
Cold  War  years  that  followed  World  War  II. 
Several  federal  agencies,  including  the  CIA,  the 
State  Department  and  the  Department  of  Defense, 
refused  to  declassify  the  documents,  citing  national 
security.   (Associated  Press.  "Bill  Would  Open 
Nazi  Crimes  Files,"  The  Boston  Globe,  August  7, 
1998,  A14.) 

[Ed.  Note:  The  President  signed  PL.  ] 05-246  on 
Octobers,  1998.  J 

Declassification  Ordered  of  Selected  Cold  War 
Documents 

A  report  from  the  Interagency  Security 
Classification  Appeals  Panel  showed  that  the  panel 
reversed  agency  decisions  and  declassified  Cold 
War  records  more  than  80  percent  of  the  time. 
Information  was  declassified  in  full  or  in  part  in  81 
out  of  the  96  documents  presented  to  it,  while 
agency  classification  actions  were  upheld  in  the 
case  of  15  documents.   ISCAP  was  established  in 
1995  when  President  Clinton  signed  Executive 
Order  12958,  the  first  effort  since  the  end  of  the 
Cold  War  to  reassess  the  balance  between  open 
government  and  the  need  to  maintain  secrets  vital 
to  national  security.  The  panel  resolves  appeals 
from  Executive  Branch  classification  decisions, 
and  can  be  reached  by  e-mail  at 
iscap@archl.nara.gov.  (White  House  Press 
Release.   "Federal  Panel  Orders  Declassification  of 
Selected  Cold  War  Documents,"  August  26,  1998.) 

September 

JFK  Assassination  Records  Released 

The  Assassination  Records  Review  Board  released 
its  final  report  in  late  September  after  releasing 
thousands  of  previously  secret  government  records 
about  the  assassination  of  President  Kennedy. 
Because  the  Board  decided  to  interpret  an 
"assassination  record"  very  broadly,  the  documents 
reveal  significant  new  insights  into  Cold  War 
foreign  policy  and  how  some  agencies  operated 
during  crises.   For  historians,  the  value  of  this 
federal  undertaking  was  seen  not  only  in  the 


Less  Access  •  June  -  December  1998  •  13 


released  documents,  but  also  in  the  broad 
implications  of  openness  for  declassification 
policy. 

While  the  Board  weighed  the  public's  right  to 
know  with  the  need  to  protect  sensitive  national 
security  information,  statute  mandated  a 
"presumption  of  disclosure."  Agency  heads  could 
only  appeal  to  the  President  to  keep  closed  those 
records  that  the  Board  decided  should  be  kept 
open.  The  Final  Report  of  the  Assassination 
Records  Review  Board  is  available  from  the 
Government  Printing  Office  (S/N  05200301472-6, 
$24)  or  online  at  http://fedbbs.access.gpo.gov/ 
libs/arrb_pdf.htm  (Miller,  Page.   "Assassination 
Records  Review  Board  Issues  Final  Report  with 
Recommendations  for  Increasing  Openness,"  NCC 
Washington  Update.  September  30,  1998.) 

October 

Head  of  CIA  Publications  Review  Board  Takes 
Pride  In  What  He  Has  "Left  In" 

John  Hollister  Hedley  heads  the  five-member 
publications  review  board  that  decides  what  former 
employees  of  the  Central  Intelligence  Agency  can 
publish  about  the  agency.  He  hates  to  be  called  a 
censor,  but  his  job  is  to  decide  how  much  the  CIA 
will  permit  to  be  revealed  about  the  inner  workings 
of  the  agency.  He  has  even  cut  information  from  a 
cookbook  of  recipes  prepared  by  CIA  agents  and 
their  spouses. 

During  the  past  three  years,  Hedley  has 
distinguished  himself  by  what  he  has  left  in,  not  by 
what  he  has  taken  out.  He  has  helped  establish 
new  standards  of  openness  that  have  allowed 
former  spies,  analysts  and  agency  officials  to  go 
farther  than  ever  before  in  describing  their 
clandestine  careers.   "I  think  we  need  to  open  up, 
and  I  think  we  can  have  it  both  ways,"  said  Hedley. 
"I  do  not  think  you  endanger  the  protection  of  that 
which  needs  to  be  protected  while  you  open  up  and 
are  much  more  transparent  than  we've  been,  in 
terms  of  what  kind  of  people  we  are,  and  what  we 
do,  and  how  we  do  it."  (Loeb,  Vernon.   "Drawing 
the  Company's  Line,"  The  Washington  Post, 


October  13,  1998,  A13.) 

National  Security  Archive  Mounts  Collection  of 
Declassified  Documents 

The  world's  largest  non-governmental  collection  of 
declassified  documents  is  the  National  Security 
Archive  Web  site  (http://www.seas.gwu.edu/ 
nsarchive/).  The  National  Security  Archive,  an 
independent  non-governmental  research  institute 
and  library  located  at  The  George  Washington 
University  in  Washington,  D.C,  collects  and 
publishes  declassified  documents  acquired  through 
the  Freedom  of  Information  Act.  It  has  assembled 
a  particularly  impressive  collection  documenting 
government  misadventures  in  Latin  America  over 
the  past  four  decades.  Other  topics  range  from 
nuclear  weaponry  and  the  militarization  of  space  to 
the  White  House  meeting  of  President  Nixon  and 
Elvis  Presley.   (Futrell,  David.   "Top  Secret 
Documents  Put  Starr's  Stuff  to  Shame."  Newsday, 
October  18,  1998,  B15.) 

November 

National  Archives  Becomes  Trove  of 
Declassified  World  War  II  Documents 

Recently  declassified  National  Archives  documents 
from  the  World  War  II  era  could  provide  a  rich 
source  of  clues  for  researchers,  historians  and 
politicians  as  to  what  happened  to  Jewish  assets 
and  bank  accounts  in  the  United  States  during  and 
after  the  war.  The  creation  of  the  U.S.  Holocaust 
Assets  Presidential  Advisory  Commission  and  the 
Clinton  Administration's  plans  to  declassify 
additional  American  intelligence  records  have 
added  additional  hope  that  bringing  together 
scattered  declassified  documents  that  may  lead  to 
long-lost  fortunes:  plundered  gold  and  assets  of 
conquered  countries  and  slain  victims,  as  well  as 
the  unclaimed  bank  accounts,  assets  and  insurance 
policies  of  Nazi  victims.  (Howe,  Desson.   "A 
Wealth  of  New  Information  on  Holocaust,"  The 
Washington  Post,  November  18,  1998,  BOl.) 


14  •  ALA  Washington  Office 


The  COGI  James  Madison  Awards 
honor  champions  of  the  public's  right  to  know 

The  James  Madison  Award,  presented  annually  by  the  CoaHtion  on  Government  Information,  honors 
those  who  have  championed,  protected  and  promoted  pubHc  access  to  government  information  and  the 
pubHc's  right  to  know.  It  is  presented  on  Freedom  of  Information  Day,  March  16,  the  anniversary  of 
the  birth  date  of  President  James  Madison.  The  CoaHtion  on  Government  Information  was  estabhshed 
by  the  American  Library  Association  in  1986.  The  Coalition's  50  member  organizations  share  a 
concern  for  loss  of  pubHc  access  to  federal  government  information. 

Recipients  of  the  James  Madison  Award: 

1998         Ben  Bagdikian,  journalist 

Wayne  P.  Kelley,  former  Superintendent  of  Documents,  Government  Printing  Office 

Eliot  Christian  and  the  U.S.  Geological  Survey 

National  Library  of  Medicine 
1997         Philanthropist  and  financier  George  Soros 
1996         The  National  Information  Infrastructure  Advisory  Council 
1995         The  Government  Printing  Office,  the  State  of  Maryland's  Sailor  Project,  the  Seattle 

(WA)  Public  Library,  and  the  Internet  Multicasting  Service's  Town  Hall  Project 
1994         Secretary  of  Energy  Hazel  O'Leary  and  former  ALA  Washington  Office  Director  Eileen 

D.  Cooke 
1993         The  legislators  who  led  the  passage  of  PL.  103-40,  the  GPO  Access  Act:  Vice  President 

Al  Gore,  original  sponsor  of  the  GPO  Gateway  to  Government  Act  when  he  was  in  the 

Senate;  Senators  Wendell  Ford  (D-KY)  and  Ted  Stevens  (R-AK);  Representatives 

Charlie  Rose  (D-NC)  and  Bill  Thomas  (R-CA) 
1992         Journalist  Nina  Totenberg,  author  Scott  Armstrong,  and  C-SPAN  founder  Brian  Lamb 
1991         Representative  Don  Edwards  (D-CA) 
1990         Senator  Frank  Lautenberg  (D-NJ),  Representative  Henry  Waxman  (D-CA),  journalist 

Philip  Shabecoff  ,  and  the  Office  of  Toxic  Substances  of  the  U.S.  Environmental 

Protection  Agency 
1989         Senator  Patrick  Leahy  (D-VT) 

Honorary  citations  also  were  presented  to  several  individuals  and  organizations  in  1996  and  1997. 

The  Coalition  seeks  nominations  for  the  annual  James  Madison  Award  and  for  honorary  citations 
in  December  of  each  year.   Send  nominations  to: 

Coalition  on  Government  Information 
c/o  American  Library  Association 

Washington  Office  tel:  800-941-8478 

1301  Pennsylvania  Avenue,  NW,  Suite  403  ^^^*  202-628-8419 

Washington,  D.C.  20004-1701  e-mail:  alawash@alawash.org 


Less  Access  •  June  -  December  1998  •  15